Skip to main content
All episodes

Episode 12

The Short Game

Does Medicare Pay for Long-Term Care? What Most People Get Wrong

Tony and Rc take on the conversation many people put off: how to think about long-term care costs. They explain the difference between Medicare and Medicaid, why Medicaid is a safety net rather than a plan for people with resources, and what to weigh before paying for care out of retirement accounts. Then Rc describes right-sizing: covering the manageable costs yourself and looking at coverage for the catastrophic ones, without buying more than you need.

Watch this episode

Worth keeping

The takeaways.

  • 1

    Putting this off is common. The episode cites a Health and Human Services figure that about 70% of people age 65 and older will need some form of long-term care, while only about 25% expect to.

  • 2

    An unresolved long-term care question can spill into other decisions. People skip the trip, the Disney visit with the grandkids, or the gift, because they aren't sure what they can afford.

  • 3

    Medicare and Medicaid are not the same thing. Medicare is the federal health insurance most people get at 65 for doctor visits and hospital stays. Medicaid is a needs-based federal-state program you have to qualify for.

  • 4

    Medicaid generally means spending down assets first (Rc says in most states, to about $2,000), and the care options may be more limited. Rc calls it an essential safety net, but not a plan if you have resources.

  • 5

    Self-funding can be a legitimate choice when it is intentional. If most of your money is in an IRA or 401(k), though, withdrawals are taxable income, so you may need to take out more than the care costs, which may also affect Medicare premiums and how much Social Security is taxed.

  • 6

    Rc's idea of right-sizing works like homeowner's insurance: pay for the manageable costs yourself and look at coverage for the catastrophic ones. A premium big enough to cause anxiety every year may be one you struggle to keep, and each option has trade-offs worth reviewing for your situation.

The conversation is not as hard as the waiting or the ignoring it.
Rc Arseneau

From this episode

Questions this conversation answers.

  • Medicare is federal health insurance that most people get at age 65, covering things like doctor visits and hospital stays. Medicaid is a joint federal and state program that is needs-based, so you have to qualify for it. Rc says people often confuse the two when they assume the government will cover long-term care.

Every word

Full transcript.

Lightly formatted from the recording. Reading time beats listening time when you're hunting for one moment.

Read the transcript ↓
Episode 12 Let's jump in. Welcome back to the Retirement Life podcast. I'm Tony Hall, here with my co-host RC Arseneau. So good to be with you again, RC, as always. RC, today we are going to talk about something nobody really likes to bring up or talk about, and that's long-term care. How do you handle that expense? How do you even think about long-term care? And here's why this matters for you, our listeners. Today, if you don't have a plan, this one thing can quietly rob you of your joy in retirement. It can sit in the back of your mind. It can steal from the life that you've worked so hard to build. But here is the good news: by the time this episode is over, you're going to have a clear picture of how to deal with this, to take that off your plate and get back to actually living your retirement. Yeah, absolutely. And before we dive in, I just want to say this: if you've been putting this conversation off, you're not alone. In fact, many statistics prove that out. There's a recent one from the Health and Human Services. It says people age 65 and older, 70% will need some form of long-term care in their lives. And that may not be surprising, but the follow-up is that many of these studies also confirm that only about 25% of us actually think we're going to need that care. So there's this big gap, and we have a tendency to not engage in this conversation because it feels like there's not a very good answer. It's just kind of chance. Hopefully we're going to change that today. So let me ask, as we get into this, in your experience, what does it actually look like when someone hasn't dealt with this? Not just the numbers, what do you see? Well, I meet people at different spots in their journey, so it depends on the timing. But oftentimes, if I meet with somebody who has not really unpacked this conversation, it's usually because they don't really understand it. They're overwhelmed, maybe they're working off of some old information, information about the way things used to work 10 or 20 years ago. But here's the thing that's almost always true: if this hasn't been addressed specifically, in a way that they know "here's how we're handling this," there's just this simmering, undone part of their plan. And it really does rob them of this peace and this freedom that they've been hoping for and anticipating in retirement, even if all of the other pieces and parts have been put together well. This one, left unaddressed, just leaves this open, simmering anxiety. Which is heartbreaking, because these are real people who have worked really hard to get to this point in their life. Absolutely. And the weight of it is real. The thing about this conversation is it really has a ripple effect into everything. It affects every other conversation that they have. Here's what I think people don't realize: the cost of not planning for this is not just financial. It turns into not feeling the freedom and the permission to do other things that you wanted to do in retirement. So you don't take the trip that you were hoping for. You don't go to Disney with the grandkids like you really wanted to, or you don't give the gift to someone that you were hoping to give, because you're not sure in the back of your mind if you can actually afford to do it. You're scared you might need this money in the future for long-term care. Yeah, and what's so hard about that is those moments don't come back. There's no rewind button. You can always make more money, but you cannot get time back. That's right. And really it's just the mental energy of it alone. It really does just feel like a weight that you're carrying around, an unresolved issue, if you will. And this whole time in retirement you're expecting it to feel like freedom. That's what we're shooting for, and for a lot of people it just doesn't, at least not fully. So when people don't have a plan, what do they typically fall back on? There are these people who just haven't planned for it, haven't made the decisions, haven't had the conversation. What do they do? What do most people assume is going to take care of this issue? Yeah. Before I answer that question, I want to say this. What I mentioned in my last statement that I think is important is that there are people that do have a plan in place, or that when they do put a plan in place, what happens is it's sometimes almost tangible when we have that conversation. Once we've locked in a solution, there's an exhale. It's like they've put to bed this worry that they didn't even realize was such a big deal. And that's what I hope happens for a lot of folks as we unpack this today. But to come back to your question, what do people fall back on if there's not a plan in place? Well, it's a great question, and this is what I hear a lot of people say. A lot of people think that Medicaid will cover this. I understand why a lot of people think that. I think there's a misunderstanding about it. There's a really big distinction between Medicaid and Medicare that a lot of people get confused. It's important to understand Medicare is the federal health insurance that most people get at age 65, and this is what covers your doctor visits, your hospital stays, all of the things you think your medical insurance would. Most people are familiar with that. Medicaid, that's a completely different animal. Not the same thing. Medicaid is a federal-state joint program that is really for people that are at poverty level. It's needs-based. You have to qualify for it, and the way you do that is you have to show that you have a need. Right. You have to have basically no assets or very little income. And so you have to spend down anything that you have, regardless of whether you think that's big or small. You have to spend it all the way down. In most states it's all the way down to around $2,000. Wow. $2,000. Before Medicaid will actually cover this. And a lot of people don't realize that that has to happen first. Wow. $2,000 is low. That's right. Imagine everything you spent a lifetime building and saving, regardless of what that dollar amount is, that essentially has to be gone before the government will step in. And the thing about Medicaid that a lot of people don't realize is they choose where you receive your care, and really the type of care. Not every facility out there accepts Medicaid patients, and some of them are more limited in the care. The quality can be different, or more limited, than private pay. For people that have limited resources, I want to make sure that I say this well: Medicaid is an essential program, and it's designed to be a great safety net for when we find ourselves in that situation. It is there for those that don't have assets to take care of themselves, so super important. But Medicaid for long-term care, if you have resources, that's not a plan. That's what happens when you don't have a plan. So that is off the table for most of our listeners, most likely. What about people who are going into it having resources and thinking, "I'll just pay for it myself"? Right, self-funding. So yes, self-funding is a completely legitimate strategy that is worth taking a look at. The idea is that you can actually absorb that full risk of whatever that is. But I want to make sure people understand that self-funding is not the same thing as putting your entire retirement at risk. Self-funding is actually intentionally saying, "We're going to set aside these dollars to make sure that we're going to take care of it if this happens." Those are different things. But here's what a lot of people don't factor in. If the vast majority of what you have in assets is in an IRA or a 401(k), these normal retirement assets, and for most of our listeners it is, this is where most people hold their wealth, every dollar you take out is taxable as ordinary income. So if you need $100,000 for care, you might have to take out $120,000, $130,000 or more, so that after taxes you get that $100,000. Right. And on top of that, when you take that $100,000 out, there's a ripple effect in your taxable income. This will increase your future Medicare premiums. It may increase how much of your Social Security income is taxed. There's just this large ripple effect that happens all at once. So you're dealing with the difficulties of this care need in crisis, and at the same time you have to wonder and worry about tax issues as well. Exactly. And I think that surprises a lot of people, because they think, "I've got the money, this is what I'll use it for," and that makes sense. The real question is how much of it is going to go to your care and how much of it is going to have to go to taxes. Once you realize that, it can change the conversation pretty significantly. So then what is the answer? Because it sounds like Medicaid isn't really a plan that will work for most of our listeners at least, and self-funding has these very real pitfalls. What do you suggest people actually do? Yeah, this is where I really hope people lean in and listen to this, because this is the part that can actually bring some relief. The answer is not "I want to buy as much insurance as I possibly can to take care of this risk." Some people have that natural reaction. And it's also not "well, let me just ignore this as long as I possibly can before I deal with it." The real answer is to do what I would call right-sizing this. Let me explain what I mean by that. Think about your homeowner's insurance, for instance. You don't insure your home for the price of a broken window. You pay for the broken window out of your pocket. You insure your home against the catastrophic loss of it burning to the ground, because that could actually impact your life if that happened. Long-term care planning works the same way. You want to self-fund those manageable risks and then lean into insurance to cover the catastrophic. Okay, so you're not trying to cover every single possible dollar of expense. That's right. And that's where people can get into trouble. If they really do the work and learn about how expensive it can be, and it can be, they want to just say, "I want to eliminate that totally. Let me get this insurance that'll cover all of the risk, and make sure it's keeping up with all the inflation, and you get all the bells and whistles." And here's the problem: you end up with a premium that is so large that every time it comes time to pay the premium, you've got this anxiety moment, and you're uncomfortable having to make that premium payment. A premium on insurance that makes you anxious every year, that's an insurance policy that's at risk of being canceled. A policy that ends up being canceled right when you need it, 15 years after you started, you don't get any of that money back. It just goes away. It ended up not being a good choice. So more isn't always better. Exactly right. More is not always better. In fact, it's usually not. So the goal should be to find that amount that protects your plan, with what matters most, from being completely destroyed by that catastrophic risk if you ever need care, but that doesn't consume all of your money and all of your resources in the meantime. There are a lot more tools out there that I think a lot of people don't realize to do that. I think a lot of people think about traditional long-term care insurance as the only option. It's either that or self-fund. With traditional long-term care, you pay this money in like you would a health insurance or a car insurance. If you don't need care, there's no benefit. Those premiums are just gone. But there are a lot more options out there now. There are policies called hybrid policies that are like long-term care policies, but they've got a death benefit attached to them, so if you don't need the care, your premium goes back to your family or charities or what have you. And there are other versions of that with life insurance and annuities. There are a lot of different ways you can approach this now that many people, I've learned, are not aware of. They're just not engaged in it. Well, and like we started the episode saying, this isn't a conversation that necessarily is fun, and certainly it's one that a lot of people avoid, but it is a conversation, just like you're saying, that is worth having. It's needed. Yeah, absolutely. And I guess if there's one thing that I could say to somebody who's just sitting on this conversation, it would be this: the conversation is not as hard as the waiting or the ignoring it. Once you actually take a look at it, you put a name to the problem and you deal with it, this weight will lift. That's worth more than any dollar amount that you have to be worried about for premiums or the cost or anything like that. Let's just have an open conversation about it. That's really, really good. And I think that's really what we want for every one of our listeners, not just a plan, but honestly to have peace. The kind of retirement that actually feels the way you imagined it, the things that you dreamed of, those longings that you had going toward retirement, that you're actually going to feel that. Yeah, absolutely. It's completely possible. You just need to be willing to have this open conversation about the risks and deal with some of that feeling, but that's what needs to happen. And we're here to help you, our listeners, do that. RC, we have something for folks who want to take the next step in this conversation, right? Yeah. This conversation can be a large conversation if you really want to dig in and learn about all the different options, all the considerations that you should be thinking about as you're wrestling with this. It can feel like a lot, but we put together a guide that just helps you take a next step. It's called Retire Without the What If, and it's designed to be a simple guide for you to learn more about long-term care planning. You can grab it. I think we'll drop a link in the show notes, and it'll walk you through everything we talked about today. Plain English, not insurance jargon or long-term care speak. No pressure. It's just good information that you can learn and that can help equip you to begin leaning into this conversation. That's great. Well, thanks so much for spending time with us today, RC. I can honestly say I've learned from just having this conversation with you today, so thank you. If this episode connected with you, please share it with someone who needs to hear it. Chances are you're not the only one carrying this around. As we've talked about in this episode, this is a discussion that needs to be had but just often isn't had. You can find us on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts, and we'd love for you to share that with others. And we will see you next time on the Retirement Life podcast.

Privacy choices

Vercel Web Analytics records anonymous page views: the page, the time, the site you came from, your device type, operating system and browser, and your approximate location. It uses no cookies and no personal identifiers, and it keeps nothing that ties your page views together for more than 24 hours.

Google Analytics measures visits. The Meta (Facebook) Pixel tells Meta when a page is viewed and when a contact or download form is submitted, so we can measure our advertising and reach people on Meta’s platforms. We do not track what you do in the Retirement Picture Check, and we never send your answers. Google and Meta may set cookies and receive your IP address, browser details and the page address. We never send them what you type into a form.

Your choice is saved in a cookie on this site for 180 days.

Analytics is off.

Privacy policy